Subtitles Transmitted on Teletext Pages

  • Thread starter Thread starter Archive7
  • Start date Start date
A

Archive7

Guest
As you probably know, there are many channels that transmit subtitles either in DVB or on teletext pages such as page 777 or page 150 for example.
There is a problem with these teletext subtitles especially for channels from Poland because some of the special Polish characters do not transmit as normal characters but look differently.
For example (part of a generated srt file):
Lines 1 and 2 are almost perfect, but lines 3 and 4 contain erroneous characters
1
00:00:00,600 --> 00:00:03,640
Chytrze pomyǁlane.

2
00:00:03,680 --> 00:00:07,560
Zapora naftowa.
Kto przez to przejdzie?

3
00:00:07,600 --> 00:00:11,360
Z lini@ Maginota te¼ sobie
nie poradz@.

4
00:00:11,400 --> 00:00:15,520
Hitler jest g¾upcem,
porywaj@c si─ na Francj─.

Even if the channel is closed, you can still see the teletext subtitles if you select any of the TTX pages. At least one of them will show the subtitles on a black screen.

There is no problem if the subtitles are transmitted as DVB.

I can't imagine anybody in Poland would be happy to see these incorrect characters, especially on their national channels.

With enough data, I can build a conversion table, but I am hoping that there is an easier way.

Perhaps there is a special plugin for Enigma 2 boxes that can correct these problems?
 
This is probably to do with the font/charset in use rather than anything Enigma2 related.
 
Captain Jack said:
This is probably to do with the font/charset in use rather than anything Enigma2 related.
Click to expand...
I am not so sure about this.
I am certain that the respective provider would make sure that the information is transmitted correctly, even on the teletext (TTX) pages.
Perhaps a Polish receiver doesn't have this problem, which means it is an Enigma 2 problem (or any other standard receiver for this matter).
 
HB13DISH16 said:
As you probably know, there are many channels that transmit subtitles either in DVB or on teletext pages such as page 777 or page 150 for example.
There is a problem with these teletext subtitles especially for channels from Poland because some of the special Polish characters do not transmit as normal characters but look differently.
For example (part of a generated srt file):
Lines 1 and 2 are almost perfect, but lines 3 and 4 contain erroneous characters
1
00:00:00,600 --> 00:00:03,640
Chytrze pomyǁlane.


Even if the channel is closed, you can still see the teletext subtitles if you select any of the TTX pages. At least one of them will show the subtitles on a black screen.

There is no problem if the subtitles are transmitted as DVB.

I can't imagine anybody in Poland would be happy to see these incorrect characters, especially on their national channels.

With enough data, I can build a conversion table, but I am hoping that there is an easier way.
Click to expand...

An observer in Poland for example
 
HB13DISH16 said:
I am not so sure about this.
I am certain that the respective provider would make sure that the information is transmitted correctly, even on the teletext (TTX) pages.
Perhaps a Polish receiver doesn't have this problem, which means it is an Enigma 2 problem (or any other standard receiver for this matter).
Click to expand...
CJ is right. Teletext operates with a specific character set, which exists in different variants.
The main difference is the language-specific characters.
A bit like codepages on old PCs.

On most STBs, the teletext fonts are bitmapped, and this determines what characters appear.
If the teletext font in your STB does not have the proper characters for Polish, you will get the lines you write.
So you need a different character set for teletext on your STB for this to display properly.

In contrast, DVB subtitles are pre-rendered bitmaps, which are merely displayed on a graphics layer.
 
Alright, I finally made the cross code table (didn't need the Enigma machine)

FYI there are 9 special Polish characters (enlarged for visual clarity)

ą

ć

ę

ł

ń

ó

ś

ź

ż

and the teletext characters representing them are

@ > ą

↑ > ć

─ > ę

¾ > ł

$ > ń

# > ó

ǁ > ś

← > ź

¼ > ż

So if you extract a subtitle file from a ts video file, based on teletext pages (DVB subtitles don't have this problem), you can easily convert the weird looking characters into the correct Polish characters

For example

1
00:00:03,770 --> 00:00:09,077
I znowu suszenie.

W ten spos#b powstaje smak.
W ten sposób powstaje smak.


2
00:00:09,751 --> 00:00:13,258
Dostrzegamy kilka much,

opr#cz nich ¼adnych napastnik#w.
oprócz nich żadnych napastników.

Hope someone might find this useful.
 
The characters cross shown above are for my receiver.
It is possible that other receivers might show different characters or even the correct ones.
 
Not much good if you do not know Polish of course:-lol
 
Are you using actual teletext and pick a page number or just pick subtitles? In teletext you can select char set to use, press teletext then menu and it will be there somewhere.

Let me know the channel and I'll test it
 
Topper said:
Not much good if you do not know Polish of course:-lol
Click to expand...
Well, one can always try to learn Polish or any other language just for fun. It is not so difficult if you really try.
Extracting the subtitles as a file this way, from a recorded *.ts file, it is very easy to convert it to any other language, English if you prefer, using Google Translation and then watch any program with English translation.
 
Captain Jack said:
Are you using actual teletext and pick a page number or just pick subtitles? In teletext you can select char set to use, press teletext then menu and it will be there somewhere.

Let me know the channel and I'll test it
Click to expand...
Brilliant. I see what you mean now.
I found a configuration page in teletext which was set to German by default. Turned it off and then selected Polish.
Now I see the special Polish characters showing as they should be on my TV.
BUT this has not made any change to the recorded subtitle stream as they still show the special Polish characters incorrectly.
It is not a big issue now. I have created a Macro in NotePad ++ that changes the characters in the *.srt file to what they should be.
 
davemurgtroyd said:
Does the same apply to Russian and other cyrilic character sets?
Click to expand...
Is there a Russian channel on Hotbird 13E that transmits subtitles with teletext?
I can test this for you.
As there are numerous characters in Cyrilic, the conversion table is going to be longer.
 
There are not. There are a couple on 5E but they are DVB subtitles.

The only one I know that transmits teletext subtitles is Channel 1 Russia in C band on 40E (TI2-MI).
 
Captain Jack said:
There are not. There are a couple on 5E but they are DVB subtitles.

The only one I know that transmits teletext subtitles is Channel 1 Russia in C band on 40E (TI2-MI).
Click to expand...
What about Ukrainian channels? Don't they use Cyrillic characters?
Unfortunately I don't have access to Amos 4W (Europe footprint) only the ME to check.
 
Captain Jack said:
Are you using actual teletext and pick a page number or just pick subtitles? In teletext you can select char set to use, press teletext then menu and it will be there somewhere.

Let me know the channel and I'll test it
Click to expand...
No particular channel at present but will soon be trying to relearn the Russian I was taught over 50 years ago and haven't really used since.Actual speech is a lot harder to follow initially - possibly down to accents.
 
davemurgtroyd said:
No particular channel at present but will soon be trying to relearn the Russian I was taught over 50 years ago and haven't really used since.Actual speech is a lot harder to follow initially - possibly down to accents.
Click to expand...
Great.
You might find that Russian movies and possibly TV series are broadcasted occasionally by non Russian channels.
I am sure that I have come across few movies in the past from premium Polish channels such as Canal+ or Canal+ Films.

The hardest part of learning Russian for me was to learn the Cyrillic characters. I think it took me few weeks to grasp it, as the brain at first interpreted the Russian characters similar to English, the way they sound in English
For example Работа (Rabota - means work) I thought it sounds as Pabota.
Does learning a new language for elderly people helps to keep Alzheimer disease away? I sincerely hope so.
 
HB13DISH16 said:
Great.
You might find that Russian movies and possibly TV series are broadcasted occasionally by non Russian channels.
I am sure that I have come across few movies in the past from premium Polish channels such as Canal+ or Canal+ Films.

The hardest part of learning Russian for me was to learn the Cyrillic characters. I think it took me few weeks to grasp it, as the brain at first interpreted the Russian characters similar to English, the way they sound in English
For example Работа (Rabota - means work) I thought it sounds as Pabota.
Does learning a new language for elderly people helps to keep Alzheimer disease away? I sincerely hope so.
Click to expand...
The alphabet is not a problem I can still remember that and count in Russian and remember a few phrases (enough to order a meal etc) but most of the vocabular has been lost in the mists of time. I have to think in a foreign language to be able to speak/write it

A few years back my German vocab was getting rusty but satellite TV brought it back up to scratch before my holiday in North Germany. Even more years ago I was fluent but Germans used to think I was from Bavaria (Bayerisch - the German equivalent of being called a Geordie) having spent some time around Lake Constance (Bodensee) and iit showed in my nuances and pronunciation. A very pleasant area with even a semi-tropical island (Mainau) in a mountain lake - probably due solar reflection from the snow on surrounding mountains.
 
Back
Top